Plants in the Eloise Butler Wildflower Garden

 

The Four Silphiums

 

 

by Gary Bebeau

Cup Plant
 

 
Compass Plant
The Eloise Butler Wildflower Garden contains four species of the genus Silphium. All are sun-loving, yellow flowered plants of the Upland Garden and are among the tallest flowers in late summer and autumn. These four are Compass Plant, Silphium laciniatum L., Cup Plant, Silphium perfoliatum L., Prairie Rosinweed, AKA Prairie Dock, Silphium terebinthinaceum Jacq. and Wholeleaf Rosinweed, Silphium integrifolium Michx. The genus name, Silphium, is from the Greek referring to resinous juice. The plant’s roots do contain resin but the name actually refers to an ancient plant of North Africa that was named “Silphium” and was said to have resinous juice that was medicinally sought after. A common name applied to many Silphiums is “Rosinweed”, again, due to the resin, but as we shall see, we have one Silphium to which that specific common name attaches. Even though these four are all yellow-ray flowers with a central disk, they are still easily identifiable - particularly by their leaves, which are all distinct.
Cup Plant
 
Compass Plant
Silphium laciniatum L.
blank
Cup Plant
Silphium perfoliatum L.
 

Identification
Characteristic
Compass
Plant
Cup
Plant
Prairie
Rosinweed
Wholeleaf
Rosinweed
Height
6 - 8 feet
4 - 8 feet
4 - 10 feet
2 - 6 feet
Leaf (photos below)
alternate
deeply lobed
rough-hairy
opposite
toothed
pierced
basal
large teeth
heart base
opposite
tiny teeth
stalkless
Stem
hairy, leafy
smooth, square
smooth, leafless
leafy
Flower Head Size
2.5 - 4 inches
2 - 3 inches
2 - 3.5 inches
2 - 3 inches
# Rays on Flower
17 - 25
16 - 35
13 - 21
16 - 33
Central Disk Size
.75 - 1.25 inches
.5 - 1.0 inches
.5 - 1.5 inches
.5 - 1.0 inches

 
Prairie Dock

As you can see from this table these plants are tall, with Prairie Dock being the tallest flowering plant in the Upland Garden. Here are the specifics on each plant.

Compass Plant: The flowers appear in several heads in long branched clusters. The common name comes from the tendency of lower leaves to be somewhat upright with the edges aligned in a north-south direction. As this plant inhabits the central United States, this fact allowed the early settlers crossing the prairies to use the plant as a sort of rough compass on cloudy days. The leaves are very deeply pinnately-divided which makes it entirely different from the others, and that is the source of the species name, laciniatum, which is from the Latin meaning “slashed” or “lacerated”.

Cup Plant: There can be several flower heads in a branched cluster. The stems are square in cross-section and smooth. Besides the height, the key feature is the opposite leaf pairs that surround the stem, appearing to be pierced by it, and forming a cup around the stem - hence the common name. The species name, perfoliatum, actually means "through the leaf," referring to the stem piercing the leaf. These cups easily collect water and are a source of liquid for birds. The plant has an extensive root system and does not transplant well except when very young.

Prairie Rosinweed (Prairie Dock): Growing from 4 to 10 feet high, this is the tallest of the four and the tallest flower in the Upland Garden. It has numerous flower heads on otherwise bare stems, the leaves being (most always) entirely basal - and quite large. They are hard to miss, with the triangular shape, heart shaped base, and large coarse teeth. The species name, terebinthinaceum, means "like turpentine." which may refer to the aroma of the resinous juice. Prairie Dock is the last of the four Silphiums to bloom, usually not until late August before any quantity of bloom is seen. The tall stems provide some vertical visual relief during the winter months.

 
Prairie Rosinweed (Prairie Dock)
Silphium terebinthinaceum Jacq.

Wholeleaf Rosinweed: This, the shortest of the four Silphiums, is the one you are most likely to encounter in a large clump. It is also the earliest of the four to bloom, usually showing open flowers in late July. There are usually a number of branched flower clusters at the top of the stem. The species name, integrifolium, is Latin for "entire-leaved" referring perhaps, to the many leaves that cover the stems. It can also refer to the leaf itself as being “entire”, that is, without teeth, but Rosinweed leaves have very tiny teeth. “Rosinweed” as a generic name has been used to refer to all Silphiums.

Native Status and Garden History: The Upland Garden was made a part of the Eloise Butler Wildflower Garden in 1944, thanks to the efforts of Martha Crone and Clinton Odell. When Martha Crone completed her 1951 inventory of all plants in the Garden, three of four Silphiums were present. Rosinweed was not on her list. Presumably it was added shortly thereafter. On the four, only two are native to Minnesota. Cup Plant and Compass Plant are native. Prairie Dock is a plant of the east central United States, not found further west than Iowa, Missouri and Arkansas. Rosinweed is reported to be native to parts of Minnesota in certain literature but the Minnesota DNR does not list the plant as native; however, it is native to much of the Central United States.

Medicinal Lore: Of the four, only Cup Plant, S. perfoliatum, has any reference in the literature as to early medicinal use of the plant. Densmore, Grieve and Hutchins all refer to the use of the root as a medicinal ingredient and give formulas and dosages. The root was used as a tonic, diaphoretic (stimulates perspiration) and diuretic. Densmore has, from her Chippewa research, perhaps the most information as she lists usage by the Chippewa for lung ailments, hemorrhage and joint pain.

Rosinweed  
Here are leaf images of the 4 plants.
Wholeleaf Rosinweed
Silphium integrifolium Michx.
 
Compass Plant Leaf Cup Plant Leaf
Above: Compass Plant
Above: Cup Plant
Below: Wholeleaf Rosinweed
Below: Prairie Rosinweed (Prairie Dock).
Rosinweed Leaf Left: An autumn photo in the Upland Garden showing the relative size of Prairie Rosinweed. Prairie dock Leaf
Prairie Dock Comparison
 

 
References: This report was compiled from many sources, all of which, including those specifically named above, are detailed on our Reference List. Gary Bebeau is a member of The Friends Board of Directors and editor of the web site. More photos of each plant will be found in the "Site Plan/Archive" or can be accessed by clicking the active links above.  
©2009 Friends of the Wild Flower Garden, Inc. All Photos are the property of The Friends. www.friendsofthewildflowergarden.org.